Hmm, if you wore them fro 2 years they must have been comfy! The website says the Anna is right and left and the Connie is straight lasted, did you have trouble with the straight lasts?
It's usually the high heel putting pressure on the ball of my foot that gives me problems in modern shoes, but they also usually have silly low uppers and you have to keep them on your feet with your toes, or they're a tiny heel and I fall off them :p